---

Political Analysis

Published: December 10, 2025
Network: Jennifer
Analysis: Conservative Caucus President Jim Pfaff

---

The redistricting fight taking place across America has emerged as a critical battleground for the future of conservative representation, with Indiana becoming the latest flashpoint in a nationwide struggle. Jim Pfaff, President of The Conservative Caucus, joined The Morning Answer with Jennifer Horne to break down why Republican-led states must aggressively pursue redistricting to counter decades of Democrat gerrymandering—and why some establishment Republicans are standing in the way.

Topics Covered

• The Current Redistricting Landscape
• Decades of Democrat Gerrymandering
• Indiana’s Political Corruption Problem
• Chamber of Commerce Opposition to Trump
• Why Republicans Must Play Offense
• The Larger Battle for Western Civilization
• Key Takeaways

The Current Redistricting Landscape

The redistricting fight has intensified following the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold Texas’s redistricting efforts. California responded with Proposition 50, which now faces its own legal challenges, with updates expected later this month. Florida, Indiana, and other states are following suit, creating a domino effect that could reshape the congressional map for the next decade.

According to Pfaff, this isn’t just about political gamesmanship—it’s about survival. “One hundred percent,” Pfaff stated emphatically when asked if he supports aggressive redistricting efforts. “Not because I think we need to gerrymander things as bad as possible… the reality is that Democrats have been gerrymandering for years on a political basis.”

Decades of Democrat Gerrymandering

Pfaff pointed to California and Illinois as prime examples of extreme Democrat gerrymandering that has effectively eliminated meaningful Republican representation in states with substantial conservative populations. California, he noted, combines aggressive gerrymandering with “jungle primaries” to create what he described as a system where “I don’t even know if there really are elections in California anymore.”

Illinois presents perhaps the most egregious example. Pfaff explained that Illinois features “possibly until California does a new map, that is the most gerrymandered state in the country.” The state contains nine districts carved into Cook County specifically designed to make Republican victories impossible.

“There are two particular ones that are interesting, south side of Chicago and south side of Cook County, that snake all the way down to almost Champaign, Illinois, like almost halfway down the state, but all the populations up in Cook County. And they’re taking all these people in rural, less populated areas and drawing them in like they belong in Chicago.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus

This type of extreme gerrymandering creates districts that stretch hundreds of miles, combining urban Democratic strongholds with rural areas to dilute conservative voting power. The result: states with 40% Republican voters end up with zero Republican representatives in Congress.

Indiana’s Political Corruption Problem

In a surprising revelation, Pfaff identified Indiana as “a corrupt state” and traced the problem directly to the Indiana Chamber of Commerce. Drawing from his extensive experience in Indiana politics during the 1990s—including running a gubernatorial campaign and working on state legislative races—Pfaff explained how the state’s business establishment has become a roadblock to conservative reforms.

The corruption, according to Pfaff, centers around corporatism that benefits major companies at the expense of smaller businesses. He cited a specific example from Mike Pence’s tenure as governor, when a “city’s movement” program initiated under Mitch Daniels sent $46 million in state funds to Evansville for economic development.

“Evansville, Indiana turned that into $2 billion of bond issuance to just expand debt and expand government,” Pfaff explained. “Of course, all the political actors that are connected with the Indiana Chamber of Commerce got a lot of money out of it.”

Chamber of Commerce Opposition to Trump

Pfaff connected Indiana’s local chamber corruption to a broader pattern of chamber opposition to President Trump and his reform agenda. He referenced the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s collaboration with unions to defeat Donald Trump in 2020, documented in a Time magazine article that detailed the coordinated effort.

Particularly notable was Neil Bradley, former chief of staff for Eric Cantor during his time as House Majority Leader, who moved to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and led efforts against Trump. Pfaff, who had opposed Bradley during his time working on Capitol Hill, called him “a real snake” and identified him as heading up the operation to defeat Trump in 2020.

“They hate Donald Trump, I guess is really what I’m trying to say. They hate things like Doge. They don’t want to give Donald Trump or Republicans nationally any favor. They just want to take care of their own right here.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus

This establishment opposition explains why some Republicans in Indiana are blocking redistricting efforts despite pressure from President Trump. The chamber-connected politicians prioritize their own financial interests and local power arrangements over national Republican success.

Why Republicans Must Play Offense

Both Pfaff and host Jennifer Horne emphasized that Republicans must abandon their decades-long defensive posture and adopt Trump’s offensive strategy. Horne articulated the core problem: “I hear a million talking heads say, well, we need to figure out how to win when Trump isn’t on the ballot. Here’s how you figure out how to win when Trump isn’t on the ballot. You start adapting his strategies and his style, which is to go and play offense and stop playing defense.”

Pfaff agreed wholeheartedly, revealing he’s working on a book titled “Against Nice” that challenges the notion that Christians and conservatives must always be passive and accommodating. “Listen, you’ve got to stop being nice,” Pfaff stated. “To Christian-thinking people out there and people of faith, there’s no biblical command to be nice. You need to fight against the culture, not fighting for fighting’s sake, but really standing on things that matter.”

This philosophy directly applies to the redistricting fight. Democrats have been aggressive in gerrymandering for decades, and Republicans who refuse to counter these tactics are essentially unilaterally disarming. “That has to be countered. You can’t sit back and not do anything about it,” Pfaff insisted. “Indiana should have done this a long time ago.”

The Larger Battle for Western Civilization

Pfaff connected the redistricting fight to a broader civilizational struggle, citing recent news about the University of Minnesota teaching programs “against whiteness”—which Pfaff interpreted as actually targeting Western civilization itself.

“The reality is the Democrat party in the far left, Zoran Mamdani or AOC or Ilhan Omar, all of them, they are literally on a course and a path to destroy Western civilization,” Pfaff argued. He noted that Western civilization “brought more freedom than has existed in human history,” including ending the practice of slavery that had been the “normal condition” throughout human history.

“Western civilization has been a benefit and a blessing to world culture. They want to destroy everything about it, where you have the rule of law and fairness and people being able to make decisions in their lives that benefit them.”
— Jim Pfaff, President, The Conservative Caucus

In this context, gerrymandering becomes more than just political tactics—it’s a tool to eliminate representation for those who defend Western values. States like Massachusetts, which have 40% Republican voters but no Republican representatives, exemplify how gerrymandering can effectively silence large segments of the population.

Jennifer Horne echoed this frustration from California’s perspective: “We’re outnumbered as Republicans here, but man, oh man, we do not have the representation of the largest group of Republicans in any state in the United States. It’s unreal.”

Key Takeaways

1. Redistricting Is Essential – Red states must aggressively pursue redistricting to counter decades of Democrat gerrymandering in states like California, Illinois, and New York, where 40% Republican populations have zero representation.
2. Establishment Republicans Are Obstacles – The Indiana Chamber of Commerce and similar establishment groups are blocking redistricting efforts because they prioritize local corruption and self-dealing over national Republican success and Trump’s reform agenda.
3. Chambers of Commerce Opposed Trump – The U.S. Chamber of Commerce actively worked with unions to defeat Trump in 2020, and state chambers continue to oppose Trump-aligned reforms like DOGE that threaten their corporatist arrangements.
4. Republicans Must Play Offense – The path to winning without Trump on the ballot is adopting his offensive strategy rather than the defensive posture Republicans have maintained for 20+ years.
5. Indiana’s Corruption Problem – Indiana’s political corruption centers on the Chamber of Commerce turning state economic development programs into self-dealing schemes, exemplified by Evansville converting $46 million in state funds into $2 billion in bond debt.
6. The Stakes Are Civilizational – The redistricting fight is part of a larger battle over Western civilization itself, as the left uses gerrymandering and other tools to eliminate representation for those defending traditional American values and institutions.
7. Biblical Mandate to Fight – Conservatives and Christians have no biblical obligation to be “nice” in the face of attacks on their values and civilization—standing firm on principles that matter is the true calling.

---

Share This Analysis

About The Conservative Caucus:
The Conservative Caucus is a grassroots public policy action organization, formed in 1974. Headed by President Jim Pfaff, the Caucus is committed to advancing free enterprise, limited government, and traditional values.

Originally broadcast December 10, 2025 on Jennifer.